There is no plausible theory under which the record of the Pentagon Papers can be interpreted as relating to the national defense.
Noam ChomskyRead
When Israelis in the occupied territories now claim that they have to defend themselves, they are defending themselves in the sense that any military occupier has to defend itself against the population they are crushing. You can't defend yourself when you're militarily occupying someone else's land. That's not defense. Call it what you like, it's not defense.
Interpretation
What this quote means
The quote critiques the justification of military defense in the context of occupation, arguing that true defense cannot occur while oppressing another population.
Noam Chomsky's quote emphasizes the moral and philosophical inconsistencies inherent in the notion of self-defense when one is occupying another's territory. He argues that the actions taken by an occupying force, which often involves violence against the local population, cannot be framed as defensive actions, as they fundamentally violate the rights of those who are being occupied. The quote challenges the justification of military responses under the guise of defense while pointing out the ethical implications of such an occupation.
Themes
OccupationDefenseMoralityPhilosophyJustificationViolence
In practice
Example use cases
In a debate on international law and human rights, one might use this quote to illustrate the complexities of occupation.
More from Noam Chomsky
All quotes →The 'free-floating intellectual' may occupy himself with problems because of their inherent interest and importance, perhaps to little effect.
Noam ChomskyRead
If you're teaching today what you were teaching five years ago, either the field is dead or you are.
Noam ChomskyRead
There are very few people who are going to look into the mirror and say, 'That person I see is a savage monster;' instead, they make up some construction that justifies what they do.
Noam ChomskyRead
The Republican Party has become overwhelmingly so extreme that it's hardly a traditional political party anymore.
Noam ChomskyRead
There is still much debate about whether torture has been effective in eliciting information - the assumption being, apparently, that if it is effective, then it may be justified.
Noam ChomskyRead
Similar quotes
There's a difference between making incremental improvements and making sweeping changes that take you away from your core values.
Tony DungyRead
In the spaniards heart is a great yearning for freedom, but only his own. A great love for truth and honor in all its forms, but not in its substance. And a deep conviction that nothing can be proven except that it be made to bleed. Virgins, bulls, men. Ultimately God himself.
Cormac MccarthyRead
Our flaws are what makes us human. If we can accept them as part of who we are, they really don't even have to be an issue.
Ellen DegeneresRead
Freedom is fragile and must be protected. To sacrifice it, even as a temporary measure, is to betray it.
Germaine GreerRead
I was a wife and mother, blameless in moral life, with a deep sense of duty and a proud self-respect; it was while I was this that doubt struck me, and while I was in the guarded circle of the home, with no dream of outside work or outside liberty, that I lost all faith in Christianity.
Annie BesantRead
Sustainability can't be like some sort of a moral sacrifice or political dilemma or a philanthropical cause. It has to be a design challenge.
Bjarke IngelsRead