Agnosticism is epistemologically self-contradictory on its own assumptions because its claim to make no assertion about ultimate reality rests upon a most comprehensive assertion about ultimate reality.
Cornelius Van TilRead
To admit one's own presuppositions and to point out the presuppositions of others is therefore to maintain that all reasoning is, in the nature of the case, circular reasoning. The starting-point, the method, and the conclusion are always involved in one another.
Interpretation
What this quote means
The quote suggests that understanding one's own beliefs and those of others reveals the interconnectedness of reasoning.
Cornelius Van Til's statement emphasizes the idea that all reasoning is circular, meaning that our starting beliefs, methods of thinking, and conclusions are intimately connected. By acknowledging our own presuppositions and recognizing those of others, we can become more aware of the foundational beliefs that shape our reasoning processes, suggesting that true objectivity is difficult to achieve.
Themes
ReasoningPresuppositionsCircularPhilosophyBeliefs
In practice
Example use cases
In a debate about ethics, one might use this quote to highlight the biases in moral reasoning.
More from Cornelius Van Til
All quotes →The only proof for the existence of God is that without God you couldn't prove anything.
Cornelius Van TilRead
Similar quotes
Without an observer at a twenty three degree angle to the light being reflected off a cloud of spherical droplets, there is no rainbow. The whole universe is like that. Our spirits stand at a twenty three degree angle to the universe. There is some new thing created at the contact of photon and retina, some space created between rock and mind.
Kim StanleyRead
The roles of art, morality, religion, political faith, science itself are not to repair organic exhaustion nor to provide sound functioning of the organs. All this supraphysical life is built and expanded not because of the demands of the cosmic environment but because of the demands of the social environment.
Emile DurkheimRead
And I think that, at some point, I am, as John Lewis and many others, are a bridge-builder. The goal is to bring America together and Americans. We are a great nation. But we must become a greater nation.
Martin Luther King IiiRead
Mob rule and emasculation of the wise' and 'who will watch the guardians'?
PlatoRead
Few things in this world are more predictable than the reaction of conventional minds to unconventional ideas.
John Anthony WestRead
You know what the best kind of organic certification would be? Make an unannounced visit to a farm and take a good long look at the farmer’s bookshelf. Because what you’re feeding your emotions and thoughts is what this is really all about. The way I produce a chicken is an extension of my worldview. You can learn more about that by seeing what’s sitting on my bookshelf than having me fill out a whole bunch of forms.
Joel SalatinRead