Agnosticism is epistemologically self-contradictory on its own assumptions because its claim to make no assertion about ultimate reality rests upon a most comprehensive assertion about ultimate reality.
Cornelius Van TilRead
To admit one's own presuppositions and to point out the presuppositions of others is therefore to maintain that all reasoning is, in the nature of the case, circular reasoning. The starting-point, the method, and the conclusion are always involved in one another.
Interpretation
What this quote means
The quote suggests that understanding one's own beliefs and those of others reveals the interconnectedness of reasoning.
Cornelius Van Til's statement emphasizes the idea that all reasoning is circular, meaning that our starting beliefs, methods of thinking, and conclusions are intimately connected. By acknowledging our own presuppositions and recognizing those of others, we can become more aware of the foundational beliefs that shape our reasoning processes, suggesting that true objectivity is difficult to achieve.
Themes
ReasoningPresuppositionsCircularPhilosophyBeliefs
In practice
Example use cases
In a debate about ethics, one might use this quote to highlight the biases in moral reasoning.
More from Cornelius Van Til
All quotes →The only proof for the existence of God is that without God you couldn't prove anything.
Cornelius Van TilRead
Similar quotes
Beyond ideas, there's a field. Will you meet me there?
RumiRead
The thing about being autistic is that you gradually get less and less autistic, because you keep learning, you keep learning how to behave. It's like being in a play; I'm always in a play.
Temple GrandinRead
This is the essence of intuitive heuristics: when faced with a difficult question, we often answer an easier one instead, usually without noticing the substitution.
Daniel KahnemanRead
Ireland sober is Ireland stiff.
James JoyceRead
I do not know if you remember the tale of the girl who saves the ship under mutiny by sitting on the powder barrel with her lighted torch... and all the time knowing that it is empty? This has seemed to me a charming image of the women of my time. There they were, keeping the world in order... by sitting on the mystery of life, and knowing themselves that there was no mystery.
Isak DinesenRead
In the end, like the Almighty Himself, we make everything in our image, for want of a more reliable model; our artifacts tell more about ourselves than our confessions.
Joseph BrodskyRead