An extravagance is something that your spirit thinks is a necessity.
Bernard WilliamsRead
The people I really do dislike are the morally unimaginative kind of evolutionary reductionists who, in the name of science, think they can explain everything in terms of our early hominid ancestors or our genes, with their combination of high-handed tone and disregard for history. Such reductive speculation encourages a really empty scientism.
Interpretation
What this quote means
The quote criticizes those who reduce complex human behavior to mere biological determinism.
In this quote, Bernard Williams expresses his disdain for individuals who, under the guise of scientific reasoning, simplify the intricacies of human morality and behavior to the evolutionary processes or genetic factors. He argues that this reductive approach lacks imagination and historical context, and ultimately leads to a superficial understanding of human nature that undermines ethical and moral considerations.
Themes
MoralityScienceEvolutionHistoryHuman BehaviorReductionism
In practice
Example use cases
During a lecture on the limits of scientific explanation in understanding human nature.
More from Bernard Williams
All quotes →There was never a night or a problem that could defeat sunrise or hope.
Bernard WilliamsRead
Contemporary moral philosophy has found an original way of being boring, which is by not discussing moral issues at all.
Bernard WilliamsRead
The majority of philosophers are totally humorless. That's part of their trouble.
Bernard WilliamsRead
People have been predicting the death of philosophy since the 17th century. When I was a student, people were saying, 'We're in the last days of philosophy.' Then we were told in the '60s it would be replaced by sociology, then by literary criticism.
Bernard WilliamsRead
Virtually the only subject in which one could ever get a scholarship to Oxford or Cambridge was classics. So I went to Oxford to study classics and, unlike Cambridge, it had a philosophy component, and I became completely transported by it.
Bernard WilliamsRead
Similar quotes
It is unacceptable that more than 1 billion people are hungry every day while another billion are obese.
Paul PolmanRead
People? People are chaotic quiddities living in one cave each. They pass the hours in amorous grudge and playback and thought experiment. At the campfire they put the usual fraction on exhibit, and listen to their own silent gibber about how they're feeling and how they're going down. We've been there. Death helps. Death gives us something to do. Because it's a fulltime job looking the other way.
Martin AmisRead
Consult: To seek approval for a course of action already decided upon.
Ambrose BierceRead
My internal and external life depend so much on the work of others that I must make an extreme effort to give as much as I receive.
Albert EinsteinRead
I stand four-square for reason, and object to what seems to me to be irrationality, whatever the source. If you are on my side in this, I must warn you that the army of the night has the advantage of overwhelming numbers, and, by its very nature, is immune to reason, so that it is entirely unlikely that you and I can win out. We will always remain a tiny and probably hopeless minority, but let us never tire of presenting our view, and of fighting the good fight for the right.
Isaac AsimovRead
Evil gains work their punishment.
SophoclesRead