If a victory is told in detail, one can no longer distinguish it from a defeat.
If you begin by saying, 'Thou shalt not lie,' there is no longer any possibility of political action.
Interpretation
What this quote means
Sartre suggests that strict moral principles can hinder practical and necessary actions in politics.
In this quote, Jean-Paul Sartre expresses the idea that rigid moral codes, such as a prohibition against lying, can obstruct the effectiveness of political action. He implies that political decisions often require flexibility and pragmatism, and that an absolute stance against certain actions may limit one's ability to navigate complex situations. This reflects Sartre's existentialist views on ethics, emphasizing that context and intention can sometimes outweigh absolute moral dictates.
Themes
In practice
Example use cases
During a debate on ethics in leadership, one might cite this quote to showcase the complexities of moral decision-making in political contexts.
More from Jean-Paul Sartre
All quotes βAll I want is' - and he uttered the final words through clenched teeth and with a sort of shame - 'to retain my freedom.' I should myself have thought,' said Jacques, 'that freedom consisted in frankly confronting situations into which one had deliberately entered, and accepting all one's responsibilities. But that, no doubt, is not your view.
If you are lonely when you're alone, you are in bad company.
A kiss without a moustache, they said then, is like an egg without salt; I will add to it: and it is like Good without Evil.
I wanted pure love: foolishness; to love one another is to hate a common enemy: I will thus espouse your hatred. I wanted Good: nonsense; on this earth and in these times, Good and Bad are inseparable: I accept to be evil in order to become good.
Night is falling: at dusk, you must have good eyesight to be able to tell the Good Lord from the Devil.
Similar quotes
To believe in God for me is to feel that there is a God, not a dead one, or a stuffed one, who with irresistible force urges us towards more loving.
In other words, what is supposedly found is an invention whose inventor is unaware of his act of invention, who considers it as something that exists independently of him; the invention then becomes the basis of his world view and actions.
A true libertarian supports free enterprise, opposes big business; supports local self-government, opposes the nation-state; supports the National Rifle Association, opposes the Pentagon.
Whereas there can be but one Baptism, they think they can Baptize; they have abandoned the fountain of life, yet promise the life and grace of the waters of salvation. It is not cleansing which men find there, but soiling; their sins are not washed away, but only added to. That being "born again" does not bring forth sons to God but to the Devil. Born of a lie, they cannot inherit the things which Truth has promised; begotten by the faithless, they are deprived of the grace of faith.
Never believe that the so-called random events of life are anything less than Godβs appointed order. Be ready to discover His divine designs anywhere and everywhere.
The Church is designed to nourish the imperfect, the struggling, and the exhausted.