If we fetishize trauma as incommunicable, then survivors are trapped - unable to feel truly known by their nonmilitary friends and family.
Phil KlayRead
Even if torture works, what is the point of 'defending' America using a tactic that is a fundamental violation of what America ought to mean?
Interpretation
What this quote means
The quote questions the morality of using torture as a means of defense, contrasting it with American values.
Phil Klay suggests that even if torture may yield useful information, it fundamentally contradicts the principles and ideals that America represents. The statement urges a reflection on the ethical implications of such actions and challenges the idea that any method, no matter how effective, can be justified if it undermines the nation's core values of justice and human rights.
Themes
TortureMoralityValuesDefenseAmerica
In practice
Example use cases
In a discussion on human rights practices in national security, this quote could highlight the ethical dilemmas faced.
More from Phil Klay
All quotes βIt's very strange getting out of the military, when you've lived in Iraq, and people you know are going overseas again and again. Some of them are getting injured.
Phil KlayRead
We have a tendency to think of war as this quasi-mystical thing, and that interpretation flattens the experience - by using different perspectives, I wanted to open a place for readers to compare and contrast, to make judgments, to engage.
Phil KlayRead
After the fighting is done, and even when it's still happening, apologies are often needed for the recounting of bare facts. Sometimes bare facts feel unpatriotic.
Phil KlayRead
Going to war is a rare experience in American culture, so it's easy for simple notions to gain a lot of weight. The reality is always more complex.
Phil KlayRead
Pity sidesteps complexity in favor of narratives that we're comfortable with, reducing the nuances of a person's experience to a sound bite.
Phil KlayRead
Similar quotes
License they mean when they cry Liberty; For who loves that, must first be wise and good.
John MiltonRead
Memory that yearns to join the centre, a limb remembering the body from which it has been severed, like those bamboo thighs of the god.
Derek WalcottRead
It is nothing but fanaticism and beautiful soulism to expect very much (or even, much only) from humanity when it has forgotten how to wage war.
Friedrich NietzscheRead
Zen says that if you drop knowledge - and within knowledge everything is included; your name, your identity, everything, because this has been given to you by others - if you drop all that has been given by others, you will have a totally different quality to your being: innocence. This will be a crucifixion of the persona, the personality, and there will be a resurrection of your innocence. You will become a child again, reborn.
RajneeshRead
Can there be in our age any peace that is not honorable, any war that is not dishonorable?
Charles SumnerRead
Strange, is it not, my brothers, how often in America those great watchwords of human energy - 'Be strong!' 'Know thyself!' 'Hitch your wagon to a star!' - how often these die away into dim whispers when we face these seething millions of black men? And yet do they not belong to them? Are they not their heritage as well as yours?
W. E. B. Du BoisRead