The historical profession is nowhere famous for its tolerance, but there are not many countries where historians can expect to pay for their opinions with penal servitude or the firing squad.
Our mental maps are distorted by who are the 'winners' of history and who are the powers of today.
Interpretation
What this quote means
Our perception of history is influenced by those who have succeeded and hold power today.
Norman Davies highlights the idea that our understanding of history is shaped by the narratives of those deemed 'winners.' This suggests that power dynamics influence which stories are told and remembered, leading to potential distortions in how we perceive past events and their significance in shaping the present. It encourages us to question the dominant narratives and to recognize the voices and perspectives that may be overlooked or suppressed.
Themes
In practice
Example use cases
In a discussion about social justice, this quote can remind participants to consider whose stories are told and whose are marginalized.
More from Norman Davies
All quotes →Transience is one of the fundamental characteristics both of the human condition and of the political order.
Nowadays, it is no longer possible to maintain that the Nazi-Soviet pact of 23 August 1939 was a fiction invented by bourgeois-imperialist enemies. Everyone has seen the film clips of Herr Ribbentrop landing in Moscow, and of Stalin smiling broadly as Ribbentrop and Molotov signed up side by side.
Why are some things remembered and others forgotten? That is the theme I want to pursue about the Second World War.
One might have thought that 70 years was time enough to work out what really happened in 1939. It isn't the case. Misunderstandings and misinformation abound.
I wanted to produce a book that would demonstrate not only the rich diversity of people who answered to Anders's command but also the extraordinary variety of their experiences and emotions: from death to despair, fear and longings and eventually to hope.
Similar quotes
[A]nd soon now we shall go out of the house and go into the convulsion of the world, out of history into history and the awful responsibility of Time.
I see that already in this present world I am exalted above measure by the Lord. And I was not worthy nor such a one as that he should grant this to me, since I know most surely that poverty and affliction become me better than delights and riches.
There are two levels to your pain: the pain that you create now, and the pain from the past that still lives on in your mind and body. Ceasing to create pain in the present and dissolving past pain - this is what I want to talk about now.
You’re like a lighthouse shining beside the sea of humanity, motionless: all you can see is your own reflection in the water. You’re alone, so you think it’s a vast, magnificent panorama. You haven’t sounded the depths. You simply believe in the beauty of God’s creation. But I have spent all this time in the water, diving deep into the howling ocean of life, deeper than anyone. While you were admiring the surface, I saw the shipwrecks, the drowned bodies, the monsters of the deep
I'm for truth, no matter who tells it. I'm for justice, no matter who it's for or against.
Even if you tell yourself "Today I'm going to drink coffee the wrong way ... from a dirty boot." Even that would be right, because you chose to drink coffee from that boot. Because you can do nothing wrong. You are always right. Even when you say, "I'm such an idiot, I'm so wrong..." you're right. You're right about being wrong. You're right even when you're an idiot. No matter how stupid your idea, you're doomed to be right because it's yours.