People think of black English as ungrammatical, but it bears the same relationship to standard English as contemporary Hebrew does to ancient Hebrew.
John McwhorterRead
People have been warning us that language was going to the dogs ever since Latin started turning into French. Yet the dogs in question never seem to emerge yelping on the horizon.
Interpretation
What this quote means
Language evolves over time, and concerns about its decline are often exaggerated.
In this quote, John McWhorter reflects on the historical anxiety surrounding the evolution of language, suggesting that despite frequent warnings about its decline, the dire outcomes predicted rarely come to pass. He humorously implies that language change is a natural process and that the fears of degeneration often do not materialize as anticipated.
Themes
LanguageEvolutionChangeCultureCommunication
In practice
Example use cases
This quote would be fitting in a discussion about the future of language in a linguistics class.
More from John Mcwhorter
All quotes →People banging away on their smartphones are fluently using a code separate from the one they use in actual writing, but a code it is, to which linguists are currently devoting articles.
John McwhorterRead
It would be good if teachers could genuinely understand that black English is not mistakes, it's just different English, and that what you want to do is add an additional dialect to black students' repertoire rather than teaching them out of what's thought of as a bad habit, like sloppy posture or chewing with your mouth open.
John McwhorterRead
Similar quotes
Look at almost any passage, and you'll find that a paragraph has five or six metaphors in it. It's not that the speaker is trying to be poetic, it's just that that's the way language works.
Steven PinkerRead
The living language is like a cowpath: it is the creation of the cows themselves, who, having created it, follow it or depart from it according to their whims or their needs. From daily use, the path undergoes change. A cow is under no obligation to stay
E. B. WhiteRead
A standard international language should not only be simple, regular, and logical, but also rich and creative.
Edward SapirRead
Purists behave as if there was a vintage year when language achieved a measure of excellence which we should all strive to maintain. In fact, there was never such a year. The language of Chaucer's or Shakespeare's time was no better and no worse than that of our own - just different.
Jean AitchisonRead
French is the language that turns dirt into romance.
Stephen KingRead
Words have a genealogy and it's easier to trace the evolution of a single word than the evolution of a language.
Daniel DennettRead